Safest neighborhoods in New York
United States · 33 neighborhoods · Updated October 2026
We compared 33 neighborhoods in New York on safety by day and at night. Carnegie Hill, Manhattan Community Board 8 and Windsor Terrace come out safest.
| # | Neighborhood | Safety | Day | Night |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carnegie Hill | 8.9/10 Excellent | 9.2/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent |
| 2 | Manhattan Community Board 8 | 8.6/10 Excellent | 9.0/10 Excellent | 8.4/10 Excellent |
| 3 | Windsor Terrace | 8.4/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 8.2/10 Excellent |
| 3 | Yorkville | 8.4/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 8.2/10 Excellent |
| 5 | Bath Beach | 8.3/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 8.1/10 Excellent |
| 5 | Manhattan Community Board 7 | 8.3/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 8.0/10 Excellent |
| 5 | Parkville | 8.3/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 8.0/10 Excellent |
| 8 | Bensonhurst | 8.2/10 Excellent | 8.6/10 Excellent | 8.0/10 Excellent |
| 8 | Flatiron District | 8.2/10 Excellent | 8.5/10 Excellent | 8.0/10 Excellent |
| 8 | Murray Hill | 8.2/10 Excellent | 8.5/10 Excellent | 8.0/10 Excellent |
| 8 | Gravesend | 8.2/10 Excellent | 8.7/10 Excellent | 7.9/10 Good |
| 12 | Midwood | 7.9/10 Good | 8.1/10 Excellent | 7.7/10 Good |
| 12 | Ditmas Park | 7.9/10 Good | 8.4/10 Excellent | 7.6/10 Good |
| 14 | NoMad | 7.8/10 Good | 8.2/10 Excellent | 7.5/10 Good |
| 14 | Sheepshead Bay | 7.8/10 Good | 8.3/10 Excellent | 7.4/10 Good |
| 16 | Chelsea | 7.7/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 7.5/10 Good |
| 16 | Chelsea District | 7.7/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 7.5/10 Good |
| 16 | Prospect Park South | 7.7/10 Good | 8.4/10 Excellent | 7.3/10 Good |
| 19 | Manhattan | 7.6/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 7.4/10 Good |
| 19 | Rose Hill | 7.6/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 7.4/10 Good |
| 21 | Manhattan Community Board 4 | 7.4/10 Good | 7.8/10 Good | 7.1/10 Good |
| 21 | Manhattan Valley | 7.4/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 7.0/10 Good |
| 23 | Little Italy | 7.3/10 Good | 7.8/10 Good | 7.0/10 Good |
| 23 | Albemarle-Kenmore Terraces Historic District | 7.3/10 Good | 8.0/10 Excellent | 6.8/10 Good |
| 25 | Manhattan Community Board 5 | 7.2/10 Good | 7.8/10 Good | 6.8/10 Good |
| 25 | Paerdegat | 7.2/10 Good | 7.8/10 Good | 6.8/10 Good |
| 27 | Brooklyn | 6.7/10 Good | 7.2/10 Good | 6.3/10 Fair |
| 27 | Garment District | 6.7/10 Good | 7.4/10 Good | 6.3/10 Fair |
| 29 | Brooklyn Community District 17 | 6.6/10 Good | 7.1/10 Good | 6.2/10 Fair |
| 29 | Midtown South | 6.6/10 Good | 7.4/10 Good | 6.1/10 Fair |
| 31 | Crown Heights | 6.5/10 Good | 7.4/10 Good | 5.9/10 Fair |
| 32 | East Harlem | 6.3/10 Fair | 7.4/10 Good | 5.6/10 Fair |
| 33 | East Flatbush | 6.0/10 Fair | 6.8/10 Good | 5.4/10 Fair |
How we measure it
Safety is rated for each neighborhood by AI research of local news, police and city statements and travel advice, starting from official country figures, by day and at night on one scale for every city. The overall figure is 40% the day rating and 60% the night rating. Methodology